What should you do with a home that you’ve inherited?
This can be a tremendous opportunity, but if it’s a complete surprise, you might not know which steps to take and how to decide whether to live in it, sell it, or rent it out.
We’re here to help. If you’ve inherited a house, these are the things to consider right away, and the potential decisions you’ll have to make.
Quick Summary:
|
Confirm Ownership and Probate Status
In Florida, most inherited homes must go through probate, the legal process of transferring ownership from the deceased person to their heirs, unless the property was held in a trust, had joint ownership with right of survivorship, or listed a transfer-on-death deed.
If probate is required, the estate’s executor (or personal representative) will handle it, usually with the help of an attorney. You’ll want to confirm that you legally own the property and whether there are any unpaid debts, taxes, or mortgages on the property. Find out when you’ll have a clear title to the home.
Understanding the probate process early helps you avoid costly delays or disputes later, especially if you plan to sell or rent the property.
Assess the Financial Picture
Before deciding what to do with the house, take stock of the financial details:
- Mortgage balance. Is the home fully paid off, or are there remaining payments?
- Property taxes and insurance. These ongoing costs will continue, whether you live in, sell, or rent the property.
- Maintenance needs. Older homes often require updates or repairs before becoming market ready. Property condition may drive what you ultimately do with the property.
- Fair market value. Have a local real estate professional or appraiser provide an estimate.
If you’re sharing the inheritance with siblings or other heirs, discuss whether everyone wants to keep the home or cash out their share. Renting may actually be the fairest compromise, allowing all parties to benefit from ongoing income.
Explore Your Options
Once you understand the home’s financial and legal standing, you generally have three main options:
Option 1: Sell the Property
Selling can provide immediate cash, which may be appealing if you don’t want the ongoing responsibility of managing a home. However, there are drawbacks. You’ll pay capital gains tax on any appreciation since the date of death (though the “step-up in basis” can minimize this). If the home needs repairs, you may spend money upfront to make it marketable.
Option 2: Move In or Use It as a Second Home
If you’re local, moving in might make sense, especially if it’s in a desirable area or near family. But if you already own a home or live out of state, managing two properties can become costly and complicated.
Option 3: Rent It Out
Renting your inherited home can offer the best of both worlds: you keep the property as a long-term asset while generating steady income. Let’s look at why this option makes sense, especially here in Florida where there’s lots of demand for well-maintained rental homes.
Why Renting Out an Inherited Home in Florida Is a Smart Move
Instead of letting the home sit vacant (which can invite problems like vandalism or code violations), you can turn it into a reliable income stream. Florida’s rental market, especially in areas like Orlando, Tampa, and the larger Central Florida area, remains strong, driven by population growth, tourism, and rising housing demand.
That monthly rent can cover or at least contribute to property taxes, insurance, maintenance, and even mortgage payments.
With professional management, your rental income can be hands-off, transforming a potential burden into a steady source of financial stability.
Benefit from Florida’s Rising Property Values
Florida real estate has shown consistent appreciation over the past decade. By keeping and renting the home instead of selling right away, you can benefit from long-term value growth while someone else (your tenant) helps pay for the property’s expenses.
If the home was inherited mortgage-free, that rent is mostly profit. If there’s still a mortgage, rental income can offset the cost while you build equity.
Favorable Tax Treatment
When you inherit a property, you receive what’s called a step-up in basis, meaning the property’s taxable value resets to its market value at the time of inheritance. That means if you decide to sell later, you’ll pay less in capital gains tax on the appreciation.
Additionally, as a rental property owner, you can deduct:
- Property taxes
- Mortgage interest
- Insurance premiums
- Maintenance and repairs
- Depreciation
These deductions can make rental income surprisingly tax-efficient, especially compared to other investment vehicles.
Professional Property Management Makes It Easy
If you’re worried about being a landlord, or if you live outside the area, a local property management partner can handle everything for you, including:
- Marketing and tenant placement
- Rent collection and accounting
- Maintenance coordination
- Legal compliance with Florida landlord-tenant laws
We work with new landlords who inherit homes all the time. There’s no need to become a full-time landlord. Leave the daily operations to us, and we’ll keep you in the loop as your investment grows in value.
This is a decision that requires an understanding of the local markets, whether we’re talking about the rental market or the sales market. You’ll need to consult with a CPA or a tax attorney, and you’ll need to settle a few logistical affairs before you list it on the sales market or start renting it out.
Inheriting a home is a tremendous opportunity. You’ve basically become a real estate investor without having to buy a property.
Rather than rushing to sell, consider what the home could mean for your financial future. With professional support and a clear plan, that inherited property could become one of your most rewarding investments.
We’d love to help you navigate this process. Please contact us at Park Avenue Property Management. We serve rental properties in Celebration, Orlando, Lake Buena Vista, Kissimmee, Maitland, Altamonte Springs, West Palm Beach, Tampa Bay, and throughout Central Florida.
